What to Do When Your Barbershop Gets a 1-Star Review

You just got a 1-star review.

Your first instinct is to respond immediately.

"This is ridiculous. This person is lying. I need to respond RIGHT NOW and set the record straight."

Stop.

Before you do anything, read this. Because how you handle the next 24 hours matters more than the review itself.

First: Do Nothing

I'm serious. Close Google. Put down your phone.

The worst thing you can do right now is respond while you're emotional. I've seen shop owners write responses that did more damage than the original review ever could.

Take 24 hours. Let the anger pass.

The review isn't going anywhere. But a bad response lives forever.

Assess: What Kind of Review Is This?

After you've cooled down, figure out what you're dealing with:

• Legitimate complaint — They had a real bad experience. Maybe justified, maybe not, but it happened.
• Wrong business — They meant to review the shop down the street. It happens more than you'd think.
• Competitor or fake — No record of them ever being a customer. Suspicious timing.
• Unreasonable expectations — They wanted a $10 cut to look like a $50 cut. Or they didn't communicate what they wanted.

Each type requires a slightly different approach. But the core principle is the same: respond professionally, briefly, and take it offline.

How to Respond (With Template)

Here's the response framework that works:

That's it. Short, professional, and moves the conversation offline.

What NOT to do:

• Don't argue the facts publicly
• Don't get defensive or sarcastic
• Don't blame the customer (even if they're wrong)
• Don't write a novel explaining what "really" happened
• Don't ignore it completely

Here's why: your response isn't for them. It's for everyone else reading.

Future customers will see this review. They'll also see how you handled it. A calm, professional response shows you care about customer experience. An angry, defensive response confirms their worst fears about your shop.

Why Responding Matters

And it's not just positive reviews that matter.

Ignoring a bad review sends a message: "We don't care."

Responding—even to an unfair review—sends a different message: "We take feedback seriously."

The Silver Lining You're Missing

Here's something that might surprise you:

A few negative reviews with good responses build MORE trust than a perfect 5.0 rating.

Which shop would you trust more?

Perfect ratings look suspicious. A business with zero complaints? Either they're deleting reviews, buying fake ones, or they've been open for a week.

A 4.7 with some negative reviews—where the owner responded professionally—looks real. It shows you're human, you make mistakes sometimes, and you handle them like a professional.

Can You Get Fake Reviews Removed?

Sometimes, yes.

Google will remove reviews that:

• Contain hate speech or profanity
• Are clearly spam or fake
• Are from someone who was never a customer
• Are for the wrong business
• Violate Google's other policies

To flag a review: Go to your Google Business Profile → Find the review → Click the three dots → Select "Flag as inappropriate"

But here's the reality: Google removes very few flagged reviews. Unless it clearly violates their policies, it's probably staying up.

That's why your response matters more than trying to get it removed.

The Best Defense: Prevention

Here's something most barbershop owners don't realize:

Most negative reviews are preventable.

Unhappy customers don't actually want to trash you publicly. They want to be heard. They want their problem fixed.

The review happens when they feel like they have no other option.

What if you could catch them first?

What if, before they ever got to Google, you asked how their experience was—and gave unhappy customers a private way to tell you?

The customers who would have left a 1-star review? They give you feedback privately instead. You fix the problem. They leave satisfied—or at least not angry enough to post.

The customers who loved their cut? They get sent straight to Google to leave a 5-star review.

That's how shops with 4.8+ ratings do it. They don't have fewer unhappy customers than you. They just catch them before the damage is done.

The Bottom Line

A 1-star review isn't a death sentence. A bad response might be.

The playbook:

1. Don't respond for 24 hours. Let the emotion pass.
2. Assess what type of review it is.
3. Respond briefly and professionally. Move it offline.
4. Don't argue, don't get defensive, don't ignore.
5. Remember: your response is for future customers, not this one.

A few negative reviews with thoughtful responses actually build trust.

But the best strategy? Catch unhappy customers before they ever get to Google.

Because the review you prevent is worth more than the one you respond to perfectly.

Frequently Asked Questions